Original Paintings vs Fine Art Prints: Which Should You Buy?

Woman hanging a fine art print on a wall

I often get asked this question, usually phrased something like: "Is it worth paying more for the original, or should I just get a print?" Here are a few simple pointers to help you decide.

What you're actually buying with an original

Kari Herbert with an original painting in her studioAn original painting is the one-and-only piece. It's the surface I worked directly, layer by layer, with acrylic, cold wax, pastel or charcoal — the actual physical record of that process. Go up close, and you can see the texture: ridges where wax has been scraped back, places where one colour was pulled through another while it was still wet.

That physicality is the whole point. No two originals are identical, even within a series on the same theme, because each one is a unique process, not a repeatable formula. When you buy an original, you're buying that singular object and everything that went into it — and, I always like to think that you can really feel the energy of the artist too. After all, if you stand an arm's distance away, you're  in the same space where the artist created the painting! This is also why originals hold and often increase in value over time in a way reproductions don't.



Above: holding one of my original paintings The Edge of Becoming in my studio. An original painting has a texture, vibrancy and energy that is quite unique. 

What you're actually buying with a fine art print

A fine art print is a high-quality reproduction of an original piece, produced using archival inks and acid-free paper designed to last for decades without fading. A good print — and this matters — is not the same as a poster from a homeware shop. Fine art giclée printing captures colour depth and detail far beyond ordinary printing, which is why the paintings that work best as prints are chosen carefully.

Prints let you own a piece you love at a fraction of the cost of the original, and they're a sensible way to build a collection gradually, room by room, without waiting to save for an original each time.

Weighing it up: originals

Choose an original if:

  • You want a one-of-a-kind piece with real texture and depth
  • The investment side of collecting matters to you
  • You're drawn to a specific piece that hasn't been released as a print, in which case you have the only one!
  • You appreciate owning the actual object the artist worked on
  • You love the idea of developing a connection with a living artist

Weighing it up: prints

Choose a fine art print if:

  • You love a piece but the original is outside your current budget
  • You want to furnish more than one room without a large single spend
  • You want flexibility with the sizing – fine art prints come in a variety of formats
  • You're building a collection over time and want flexibility
  • You want the option to buy the same image as a gift for more than one person

In the image above, the framed fine art print After the Rain is larger than the original much smaller painting, so fits this space better. 

A note on value

People sometimes assume a print is a lesser choice, a compromise. It isn't. A well-produced fine art print, properly framed, still brings colour, atmosphere and quality into a space - and, crucially, if you're in love with a particular piece, but it isn't the right size for your room, then you have the ability to choose a size that fits your space perfectly.

Still not sure?

Start with how the piece makes you feel, rather than fixating on the price tag. If a particular painting calls to you and you keep coming back to it, that's your answer on which piece — the original-versus-print decision is really about budget, the one-off aspect, and how you want to build your collection from there.

You can browse original paintings here or explore the full range of fine art prints here, including originals under £170 if you're starting small. And if you're torn between an original and its print version of the same piece, get in touch — I'm always happy to talk it through.


Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.